Guest book

All comments, contributions or corrections welcomed - but please remember: I am NOT the author of any of these books!


To write message



Powered by Responders.com


Latest guest book entries (most recent at top)



"Will "In Charms Way" be published? If so, when can I expect it at my local book store? I am really in love with Maggie and Marcus and Liss and all the other characters in these books.I have and have read and reread all of them.Thank you." (Gail Henry)
It is listed on Amazon as a forthcoming title, but to get in touch with Madelyn Alt directly, email her at the address given in the press section of her website (her website address is given at the foot of my Madelyn Alt page). (Philip Grosset)

"I like your site very much -- thank you." (Chris)

"I love the Michael Jecks Templar Series and was recommended to read Maureen Ash. I finished Alehouse Murders and started Squire. 12/13th century mysteries fascinate me. Love the historical fiction genre." (Bea Strong)

"I had decided to reread the Reverend Randollph series and was trying to find some more information on Charles Merrill Smith, and your site came up. I hope to do a blog post on the initial book for the "Forgotten Books Friday" seires. It's an interesting trip back into the 1970s, when mainline Protestant churches had so much more prominence, and were struggling with changing attitudes towards sexuality.
I'll make it a goal to see the Rev. Helena McKechnie, the Angel of Philadelphia, on this site sometime, though she's more in the fantasy genre than the detective. Just got to get the book polished and published." (Steve Wylder)

"You seem not to like the historical intrusions (in the
Dame Frevisse books) but to me they are what makes these books - and the Brother Cadfeal books - so interesting, that they are placed in a historical context and that we readers get to see how the characters react and interact with their times and the larger events. Would it be more interesting to you to read about a character on 9/11/01 where there was no mention of the terrorist attack? Where the characters couldn't react to it? I guess it's because I came to these books as a history lover tired of dry history books and not as a mystery lover." (Leonard Marks)
Yes, but the historical background is handled so much better in the Cadfael books than in the Frevisse ones. (Philip Grosset)

"Hi Philip! I am a crime writer and I mentioned your wonderful site in my latest interview. Brian Drake interviewed me about spirituality and morality in crime fiction. Here's the link: http://briandrake88.blogspot.com/2011/10/anonymous-9-visits-your-humble.html
Please drop by and leave a comment if you wish. Also, if you care to tell your readers about the interview, we would love to see some God-loving, crime reading folks drop by. Best wishes. (Anonymous-9)

"Liked your page on
Rabbi Small." (Carol)

"Naturally I disagree with your ranking of Innes' books--how could I not? While I totally agree that the much admired "Lament for a Maker" is virtually unreadable (though the brief part set in Australia is good---Innes lived there from 1935-1940), "Appleby on Aarat" is one of my favorites. Yes, the story is absurd, but there is much in it to savor, for instance, the relationship between Appleby and the Australian woman, who is described as being "like a good linoleum, which wears the same all through." Remember how she drags the various unconscious ship survivors into the shifting shade of the sail?" (E Babcock)

"It's interesting to find someone who likes the Sister Fidelma series and yet can be critical when needed. I, too, find the layers of Irish heritage for one character distracting." (M E Kemp)

"Thank you, thank you, thank you!! I was too stupid to take down the name of the delightful detective Catherine Levendeur or the author, Sharan Newman, the first time I read one of the books. Finally I can read some more of these wonderful stories thanks to your website." (Kris)

"As a man of mathematics, I have always enjoyed books about detection during my 87 years. Today, there is a wealth of detective fiction that is founded on historical fact, and that is where my current reading lies. I've been wading through books by the members of the Medieval Murderers, over the past few years, and I have three books, and an ebook by Susanna Gregory on my desk as I write. Tonight, I am building up my information about this excellent author from the internet. Best wishes frm Tropical North Queensland." (Arthur)

"Thanks for the summaries of Brodrick's novels. I'm reading A Whispered Name. Just loving it. It combines several of my pet interests: the Great War, legal matters/court martials and problems of religious convictions and spirituality. Great writer too!" (Bernadette Trotter)

"Looking to see if there was a new Sisterr Agatha: Love sister Agatha. Please write more."(mary rogge)

"Possibly I did not see all your stuff--I saw a lot about nuns. As far as I could see, You didn't evven mention G. K. Chesterton's Father Brown." (Rima Segal)
Try looking under B for Brown on the contents list. All the best. (Philip Grosset)

"I read there was a Jesuit program in Seattle that trains lay people in the art of spiritual direction. Is that true?" (Timothy G Verkist)
I'm afraid I have no idea! My site is about clerical detectives in crime fiction. But look up Jesuit retreat centers Seattle in Google and you'll find there are several. (Philip Grosset)

"Hi, I've just discovered your site. Do you know of any Reformed/Presbyterian detectives? Thanks." (David A)
Yes, there are a number of Presbyterian detectives.The easiest way to find them is to put in the word Presbyterian in the search engine at the foot of my contents page. (Philip Grosset)

"So much information ... a real delight to browse through it!! My compliments." (Alex)

"Loved it. Did you include the series where a lawyer investigated dark doings at monasteries etc in the reformation for his boss Cromwell? (I cant remember but I did like it and think it counts)." (Robyn Campbell)
You're thinking of the Matthew Shardlake series, including "Dissolution" by C J Sansom. I'll have another look at it but am not sure that lawyer Dr Shardlake can really qualify as any sort of clerical detective! (Philip Grosset)

"I have another author and character to commend to you. The author is Judith Rock and that character is Maitre Charles duLuc, a Jesuit master in 17th century Paris, He is a former musketeer (English spelling) as well as a ballet instructor. DuLuc appears in The Rhetoric of Death and The Eloquence of Blood (Berkley Press). They are well written and historically fascinating. Rhetoric of Death deals with the Huguenots and consequences of the Edict of Nantes." (Rev Phil White)
Many thanks. I've now added a page on
Charles du Luc. (Philip Grosset)

"Hello. Re Montague Egg: 'Plummet[sic] and Rose (signifying death and resurrection)...' BUT "Plummer" later! I don't have the book to hand, but surmise that a light scrambling may have occurred. Kind regards, Barry McAleenan".
PS. I've forgotten your name but daren't revert to the HOME page, for fear of losing my details input.
Many thanks for the correction. It should be Plummet and Rose. (Philip Grosset)

Goodness, no Bishop Blackie? Greeley writes a lot & seems to be somewhat obssessed with sex; the earlier novels are more intense and complicated; the more recent are frankly light-hearted pot-boilers and I like them better. I loved the site but was very startled to realise that my collection - and a recent move had every single removalist muttering "I've never SEEN so many bookcases" - has barely skimmed this rich subgenre." (Diane Campbell, Australia)

You'll find that Bishop Blackie is listed under his original full name: Father Blackie Ryan. (Philip Grosset)

"Forthcoming clerical detectives include the Reverend Tom Christmas in C.C. Benison's Twelve Drummers Drumming and the Reverend Max Tudor in G.M. Malliet's Wicked Autumn." (David Blackwater)
Many thanks for the info. I've now added Wicked Autumn.

(Philip Grosset)

"Many thanks for your review of my book Pain Wears No Mask. Your coverage of this sub-genre is remarkable. While I understand that all reading is subjective, I'm a little surprised that the violence - admittedly of which there is plenty - dominated the comments. At the various rewrite stages two literary agents (one being Lugi Bonomi, no less) wanted me to provide more violence for the modern reader and make the nun more violent. Ho hum.
Other reviews tended to focus on the tender moments, the budding romance between Adam, the detective, and Rose, which you seem to have ignored. I've been asked if I was in the police and some, unsure of the author's gender, wondered if I'd been a nun! One reader, an ex-nun, has read the book three times and wants a sequel. Ah, well. Thanks again." (Nik Morton)



Go on to see OLDER GUESTBOOK ENTRIES or return to CONTENTS LIST

Return to
CONTENTS LIST

"